Competence is not a certificate
A certificate shows you passed a course on one day. Competence is whether you can do the work, properly, today. The law asks for the second.
By Jonny MillardReviewed by Jonny Millard,
In short
Competence is the skills, knowledge, experience and behaviours needed to do a piece of work properly. A certificate is evidence of part of that, usually knowledge, on the day you were assessed. Since 1 October 2023 the Building Regulations in England have required competence for design and building work, so a card or a certificate on its own does not answer the question.
What a certificate actually proves
A certificate proves that, on a given day, you met the bar set by whoever issued it. That is worth having. It is also narrow. It says nothing about the work you have done since, whether you have kept up, or what you do when the job gets awkward.
Most of the industry still treats the card as the answer. Somebody asks "are they competent?" and gets handed a certificate. The question and the answer are about different things.
What the law means by competent
Part 2A of the Building Regulations 2010 puts it in four words. Anyone carrying out design or building work must have the skills, knowledge, experience and behaviours necessary for that work. The regulations do not define the four words. In plain terms:
- Skills. You can do the task to the standard it needs.
- Knowledge. You understand why it is done that way, and what goes wrong when it is not.
- Experience. You have done it on real work, enough times to handle what a classroom never shows you.
- Behaviours. You do it properly when nobody is checking, and you stop and say so when something is beyond you.
A course can teach knowledge and test some skill. Experience and behaviours only show up over time, on real work. No certificate covers all four.
A certificate is evidence. Competence is the judgement someone makes from all the evidence.
Who decides
Not the certificate, and not a piece of software. A person does: an employer taking someone on, or a client appointing a designer or a contractor.
The regulations expect whoever appoints to take all reasonable steps to satisfy themselves that the person is competent. That means looking at evidence and making a judgement they can stand behind later.
What good evidence looks like
Evidence that stands up
- Qualifications and course results, with the issuer named.
- A record of real work: what, where, when, and who can confirm it.
- Proof it is current: recent work, refreshers and CPD.
- Evidence of behaviour: feedback from supervisors, and how problems were raised and handled.
- A clear label on every item saying whether an issuer verified it or you added it yourself.
What this means for you
If you do the work, keep more than your cards. Keep a record of what you have done and who can vouch for it. If you appoint people, ask for more than a certificate, and keep a note of what you checked and why you were satisfied.
Where BeCompetent fits
BeCompetent is a record of that evidence: learning, qualifications and evidence from site, each item labelled with where it came from. It shows the evidence. It never declares anyone competent. That decision stays with a person.
Sources
A plain-English summary, not legal advice.
Who wrote this
Jonny Millard, Founder, BeCompetent. Jonny runs BeCompetent and UK Fire Door Training, which trains thousands of people a year for work in the built environment.